Goodness, Fadiman does not include any books of the Bible in his list, the Pentatuch, Psalms, Isaiah, Song of Solomon, the Gospels, both Corinthians, Galatians, Romans, Phillipians, Ephesians, et al.
But to keep on topic, the only books I know to have been stolen are college textbooks, in my husband's case a calculus text that was used for more than a year's worth of classes.