begging the question


	Wordsmith Talk		About Us \| What's New \| Search \| Site Map \| Contact Us

Register Log In
Wordsmith.org Forums General Topics Q&A about words begging the question

Search

Advanced Forum Search

Forums Calendar Active Threads

Previous Thread

Next Thread

Print Thread

Re: begging the question: a dissenting view

#13565 12/21/00 01:37 PM

Joined: Dec 2000

Posts: 13,803

Faldage

Carpal Tunnel

Faldage

Carpal Tunnel

Joined: Dec 2000

Posts: 13,803

misuse of the term "begging the question."...a logical fallacy in which the truth of the conclusion is assumed by the premises

If the logicians were so logical they should have called it "Assuming the Conclusion" instead of giving it a name that doesn't describe it so well.

What? Petitio Principii? Gimme a break!

Copy Link to Clipboard

Share Post on Facebook

Share Post on Twitter

Entire Thread

Subject Posted By Posted

begging the question metameta 12/20/00 04:30 PM

Re: begging the question NicholasW 12/20/00 04:33 PM

Re: begging the question Bobyoungbalt 12/20/00 04:44 PM

Re: begging the question metameta 12/20/00 04:58 PM

Hope TEd Remington 12/20/00 06:11 PM

Re: Hope paulb 12/21/00 12:45 AM

Re: begging the question wow 12/21/00 12:30 PM

Re: begging the question NicholasW 12/21/00 12:54 PM

Re: begging the question Jazzoctopus 12/21/00 08:46 PM

Re: begging the question NicholasW 12/22/00 08:23 AM

Re: less = fewer NicholasW 12/22/00 11:12 AM

Re: less = fewer Jazzoctopus 12/22/00 03:06 PM

Re: less = fewer Faldage 12/22/00 05:35 PM

Re: less = fewer Capital Kiwi 12/22/00 05:59 PM

Less and fewer are traditionally different TEd Remington 12/22/00 06:17 PM

Re: Less and fewer are traditionally different NicholasW 01/02/01 10:56 AM

Re: Less and fewer are traditionally different Capital Kiwi 01/02/01 05:28 PM

Re: Less and fewer are traditionally different Faldage 01/03/01 02:22 AM

Re: Less and fewer are traditionally different Max Quordlepleen 01/03/01 02:48 AM

Re: Less and fewer are traditionally different NicholasW 01/03/01 08:14 AM

Re: less = fewer of troy 12/22/00 07:56 PM

Re: less vs. fewer Faldage 12/22/00 08:35 PM

Re: less = fewer Jazzoctopus 12/27/00 10:56 PM

Ownership of Languages Capital Kiwi 12/28/00 12:55 AM

Re: Ownership of Languages Bobyoungbalt 12/28/00 04:40 PM

Re: Ownership of Languages Capital Kiwi 12/28/00 06:26 PM

Re: Me is good Faldage 12/28/00 07:15 PM

Re: Me is good AnnaStrophic 12/28/00 08:46 PM

Re: Me is good (Don't get me wrong) Faldage 12/28/00 09:08 PM

Re: Me is good Bobyoungbalt 01/02/01 07:10 PM

Re: Me is good wsieber 01/03/01 07:45 AM

Re: Me is good Bobyoungbalt 01/03/01 03:49 PM

Re: English is "Easy" Capital Kiwi 01/03/01 05:37 PM

Order Different Word in Languages Hyla 01/03/01 07:38 PM

Re: Order Different Word in Languages Capital Kiwi 01/03/01 07:58 PM

Re: Order Different Word in Languages Hyla 01/03/01 08:08 PM

Re: Order Different Word in Languages Capital Kiwi 01/03/01 09:44 PM

Re: Order Different Word in Languages NicholasW 01/04/01 09:26 AM

Re: Order Different Word in Languages Bingley 01/06/01 02:51 PM

Re: Indonesian word order NicholasW 01/08/01 11:18 AM

Re: Indonesian word order Bingley 01/09/01 03:39 AM

Re: Indonesian word order NicholasW 01/09/01 08:12 AM

Re: Indonesian word order Bingley 01/09/01 09:12 AM

Re: Indonesian word order Bingley 01/10/01 04:22 AM

Re: Order Different Word in Languages belMarduk 01/03/01 10:16 PM

Re: Me is good NicholasW 01/03/01 08:25 AM

Re: Me is good Faldage 01/03/01 02:41 PM

Thank You Faldage! Hyla 01/03/01 04:20 PM

Re: Scentific Testing Capital Kiwi 01/03/01 05:30 PM

Re: Scentific Testing Faldage 01/03/01 06:58 PM

Re: Scentific Proving Faldage 01/04/01 04:41 PM

Re: Scentific Proving Capital Kiwi 01/04/01 04:48 PM

Re: Rule wsieber 01/04/01 06:23 AM

Re: Rule NicholasW 01/04/01 09:16 AM

Re: Rule Hyla 01/04/01 03:56 PM

Re: Rule Faldage 01/04/01 04:36 PM

Re: Rule wsieber 01/05/01 07:01 AM

Hmmmm..... shanks 01/05/01 01:49 PM

Re: rule wsieber 01/08/01 07:17 AM

Eprouvette NicholasW 01/05/01 10:45 AM

Re: Eprouvette belMarduk 01/06/01 12:43 AM

Re: Eprouvette Capital Kiwi 01/06/01 03:16 AM

Re: Who owns the language? Phyllisstein 01/08/01 01:29 PM

Re: Who owns the language? Jackie 01/08/01 03:48 PM

Re: Who owns the language? metameta 01/08/01 03:48 PM

Re: Who owns the language? musick 01/11/01 05:49 PM

Re: Who owns the language? metameta 01/12/01 04:40 AM

Re: Who owns the language? musick 01/12/01 09:11 PM

Re: hoi polloi Faldage 01/08/01 04:46 PM

Re: hoi polloi Jazzoctopus 01/08/01 09:17 PM

Re: hoi polloi Max Quordlepleen 01/08/01 09:25 PM

Re: hoi polloi tsuwm 05/30/01 03:54 PM

Re: begging the question wmlewis 01/09/01 03:38 PM

Re: begging the question: a dissenting view Faldage 12/21/00 01:37 PM

Re: begging the question: a dissenting view metameta 12/21/00 03:37 PM

Re: begging the question: a dissenting view tsuwm 12/21/00 03:43 PM

Re: begging the question: a dissenting view Phyllisstein 01/09/01 07:06 AM

Re: begging the question: a dissenting view Capital Kiwi 01/09/01 08:39 AM

Re: begging the question: a dissenting view Phyllisstein 01/09/01 03:14 PM

Re: meanings of beg tsuwm 01/09/01 03:23 PM

Re: meanings of beg jmh 01/10/01 09:44 AM

Re: meanings of beg of troy 01/10/01 01:32 PM

Re: Inverted Punctuation Capital Kiwi 01/10/01 08:04 PM

Re: begging the question: a dissenting view metameta 01/10/01 04:16 AM

Re: begging the question: a dissenting view wsieber 01/11/01 06:06 AM

Re: begging the question: a dissenting view Capital Kiwi 01/10/01 05:20 AM

From sewing to furniture?? TEd Remington 01/10/01 05:36 PM

Re: From sewing to furniture?? Jackie 01/10/01 06:49 PM

Re: From sewing to furniture?? jmh 01/10/01 11:12 PM

Re: From sewing to furniture?? Jackie 01/11/01 02:11 AM

Threads Phyllisstein 01/11/01 11:09 AM

Re: Threads metameta 01/11/01 03:32 PM

Re: Threads wow 01/11/01 04:10 PM

Re: Threads of troy 01/12/01 07:10 PM

Re: Threads musick 01/12/01 09:23 PM

Re: Threads Capital Kiwi 01/13/01 05:42 AM

Re: Threads Bobyoungbalt 01/11/01 04:12 PM

Re: Threads TEd Remington 01/11/01 05:59 PM

Re: Threads Capital Kiwi 01/11/01 09:13 PM

Re: Threads Phyllisstein 01/12/01 07:24 AM

Re: begging the question TEd Remington 12/21/00 03:52 PM

Re: begging the question metameta 12/21/00 04:46 PM

Re: begging the question Capital Kiwi 12/21/00 05:14 PM

Re: begging the question jmh 12/21/00 08:25 PM

Re: begging the question belMarduk 12/29/00 05:55 PM

Re: begging the question Faldage 12/29/00 06:28 PM

Re: begging the question tsuwm 12/29/00 10:23 PM

Moderated by Jackie

Hop To

Print Thread

Switch to Flat Mode

Show Likes

Link Copied to Clipboard

View Profile
Private Message
Website
Follow User
Forum Posts
Like Summary

Forum Statistics

Forums16

Topics13,913

Posts229,361

Members9,182

Most Online3,341
Dec 9th, 2011

Newest Members

Ineffable, ddrinnan, TRIALNERRA, befuddledmind, KILL_YOUR_SUV
9,182 Registered Users

Who's Online Now

0 members (), 739 guests, and 5 robots.

Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod

Top Posters(30 Days)

wofahulicodoc 35

A C Bowden 22

LukeJavan8 3

ddrinnan 1

Top Posters

wwh 13,858

Faldage 13,803

Jackie 11,613

wofahulicodoc 10,557

tsuwm 10,542

LukeJavan8 9,919

Buffalo Shrdlu 7,210

AnnaStrophic 6,511

Wordwind 6,296

of troy 5,400

Forum Rules · Mark All Read Contact Us · Forum Help · Wordsmith.org

Disclaimer: Wordsmith.org is not responsible for views expressed on this site. Use of this forum is at your own risk and liability - you agree to hold Wordsmith.org and its associates harmless as a condition of using it.

Wordsmith Talk

Wordsmith.org Forums General Topics Q&A about words begging the question