Past Conditional for Subjunctive? | Q&A about words

You are not logged in. [Log In] Wordsmith.org » Forums » General Topics » Q&A about words » Past Conditional for Subjunctive?

Topic Options

#56109 - 02/09/02 08:05 PM Past Conditional for Subjunctive?
Pivetta stranger Registered: 02/09/02 Posts: 2	Sometimes I hear well-spoken people say, "I wish I would have known." Is this grammatically correct? Shouldn't it be, "I wish I had known"?
Top

#56110 - 02/09/02 08:53 PM Re: Past Conditional for Subjunctive?
GallantTed enthusiast Registered: 11/07/01 Posts: 273 Loc: Ireland	Howya Pivetta I'm probably not the best one ta be welcomen ya, but there doesn't seem ta be anyone else around. There's usually loads of brainy people here what can answer yer questions. I'm not so sure meself and at furst glance I'd say yer right ta question "I wish I would have known". On the other hand, ya always say "I wish I were" in the conditional so mabee it's a folly on from that or somethin. I can't be knowen meself, but I'm sure someone will help ya soon. Be seein ya GallantTed - yer trouble shooten, problem solven Teddy Bear. PS - what's anarcho-capitalism? Can bears catch it?
Top

#56111 - 02/09/02 09:21 PM Re: Past Conditional for Subjunctive?
wwh Carpal Tunnel Registered: 01/18/01 Posts: 13858	Dear Pivetta: I have forgotten all the grammar I once knew, and all our experts must be watching the Olympics. I would never use the "would" in your example. "I wish I could have known.." seems OK, or simpler "I wish I had known."
Top

#56112 - 02/09/02 09:32 PM .
Max Quordlepleen Carpal Tunnel Registered: 08/12/00 Posts: 3409
Top

#56113 - 02/09/02 10:39 PM Re: Past Conditional for Subjunctive?
slithy toves enthusiast Registered: 01/29/02 Posts: 320 Loc: Sarasota, Florida, US	Dear Pivetta, I'm a stranger here myself, and I hope you will be made to feel as welcome as I have. "If I had known" is the way to go in the subordinate clause. "Would have" sounds right in the main clause. It has to do with what happened first and what came later.
Top

#56114 - 02/10/02 08:06 AM Re: Past Conditional for Subjunctive?
Faldage Carpal Tunnel Registered: 12/01/00 Posts: 13803	"I wish I would have known." ... "I wish I had known"? See this http://www-personal.umich.edu/~jlawler/aue/tense.html for a glimpse into the wonderful world of nuance the English language is capable of.
Top

#56115 - 02/10/02 09:14 AM Re: Past Conditional for Subjunctive?
wow Carpal Tunnel Registered: 11/25/00 Posts: 3439 Loc: New England, USA	Welcome to the Board Pivetta! For what it's worth, when I am truly rueful I say : "I wish I'd've known" which, I guess, is a contraction of "I wish I would have known" ... it's all too complicated, this language of "ours!" I tend to go with what sounds right but I wish I'd paid more attention in school. Tsuwm will help you out ... now that he is no longer hiding his brilliant light under a barrel! (See "a nother promise" thread in Information and Announcements)
Top

#56116 - 02/10/02 05:23 PM Re: Past Conditional for Subjunctive?
Jackie Carpal Tunnel Registered: 03/15/00 Posts: 11613 Loc: Louisville, Kentucky	A hearty welcome to you, Pivetta! I'd sort of thought that 'I had known' was correct, and the other a sloppy but common idiom. Apparently I was wrong. Looked at your bio, Sweetie--you seem to have enough quirkiness to fit right in here! Re: your special interest, musick likes baseball pretty well, but you really ought to check in with AnnaStrophic and Faldage, for some real die-hard fan discussion. Just a suggestion.
Top

#56117 - 02/10/02 08:23 PM Re: Past Conditional for Subjunctive?
hev addict Registered: 01/28/02 Posts: 477 Loc: Sydney, Australia	"I wish I had known" This one gets my vote, Pivetta. While we are at it, you get my WELCOME and MaxQ gets my hearty thanks for expressing how I feel about this site: I have stayed out of this thread to date because my grasp of grammar isn't worth ...(read MaxQ's post for the rest) ... ask more questions - that way I can learn vicariously. Glad you're (both) here Hev "no longer a stranger..."
Top

#56118 - 02/10/02 10:07 PM Re: Past Conditional for Subjunctive?
Bobyoungbalt veteran Registered: 11/22/00 Posts: 1289	Welcome Pivetta! Fans of mystery novels (I am one) refer to the "Had-I-But-Known School" of mystery writing, the greatest practitioner of which was Mary Roberts Rinehart. That's a rather old-fashioned way of expressing the same thing.
Top

Moderator: Jackie

Forum Stats

8946 Members
16 Forums
13866 Topics
222180 Posts

Max Online: 3341 @ 12/09/11 02:15 PM

Newest Members


	Wordsmith Talk		About Us \| What's New \| Search \| Site Map \| Contact Us

Wordsmith Talk