Art is communication between human beings without word/symbols, about mutually shared conditions of being alive.
what about literature? Literature ain't art or somethin'?
- and what about theatre? Theatre ain't art, huh?
- and what are "words", anyway? Communication using sounds of a more or less conventional nature?
Music, other than singing, isn't exactly words, but it ain't far short of it, either. please don't say music isn't art - not while dub-dub is listening!
Mind you, milum, I agree with much of what you teach, and one person's art is another person's phart - or vice versa.
Isn't it strange that olfactory art has never really been developed, other than commercially.