|
Joined: Jul 2000
Posts: 3,467
Carpal Tunnel
|
Carpal Tunnel
Joined: Jul 2000
Posts: 3,467 |
Spart:
I remember that passage when I read the book, and at the time I took it as hyperbole.
English has no verb form that pins down the time. I attack, I do attack, I am attacking. I attacked, I have attacked.
If I want you to attack now, I say, "Attack now." I don't say, "Oh, whenever you get around to it, and when you thing all the omens are right, move forward and shoot a few of the enemy over there on the right flank." Actually, strategic orders generally do not supply specifics such as "attack now" though they do at the tactical level.
I took both Russian and German, many years ago, and I don't remember any verb forms along the lines Turtledove was implying. I think most languages would use adverbial formations to get across the point of timeliness. Latin definitely uses adverbs (nunc (now) comes immediately to mind.) And notice how "immediately" works in the last sentence.
In looking back at your quote I'm coming to the conclusion that Turtledove was just prattling on to get a few more words on paper. He's really good at that. (though i still enjoy his stories!)
Ted
TEd
|
|
|
Entire Thread
|
Chicken or Egg, continued
|
Sparteye
|
10/10/02 05:37 PM
|
Re: Chicken or Egg, continued
|
wwh
|
10/10/02 06:07 PM
|
Re: Chicken or Egg, continued
|
vika
|
10/11/02 07:59 AM
|
Re: Chicken or Egg, continued
|
vika
|
10/11/02 02:11 PM
|
Re: Chicken or Egg, continued
|
Faldage
|
10/11/02 02:31 PM
|
Re: Chicken or Egg, continued
|
AnnaStrophic
|
10/11/02 02:41 PM
|
Re: Chicken or Egg, continued
|
Faldage
|
10/11/02 02:49 PM
|
Re: Chicken or Egg, continued
|
milum
|
10/10/02 06:39 PM
|
What is the "English" verb form of "right now"?
|
TEd Remington
|
10/10/02 06:48 PM
|
Re: Chicken or Egg, continued
|
TEd Remington
|
10/10/02 07:01 PM
|
Re: Chicken or Egg, continued
|
Kupatchka
|
10/12/02 04:34 PM
|
Re: Chicken or Egg, continued
|
Bobyoungbalt
|
10/12/02 04:43 AM
|
Re: Chicken or Egg, continued
|
Faldage
|
10/12/02 02:49 PM
|
Re: Chicken or Egg, continued
|
Bobyoungbalt
|
10/13/02 01:53 AM
|
Re: Chicken or Egg, continued
|
Faldage
|
10/13/02 11:25 AM
|
Re: Chicken or Egg, continued
|
Bobyoungbalt
|
10/14/02 02:53 AM
|
Re: Chicken or Egg, continued
|
Capital Kiwi
|
10/14/02 05:36 AM
|
Re: Chicken or Egg, continued
|
Faldage
|
10/14/02 10:07 AM
|
Re: Chicken or Egg, continued
|
Capital Kiwi
|
10/14/02 08:22 PM
|
Re: Chicken or Egg, continued
|
Faldage
|
10/14/02 08:25 PM
|
Re: Chicken or Egg, continued
|
Capital Kiwi
|
10/14/02 08:34 PM
|
Re: Chicken or Egg, continued
|
Alex Williams
|
10/14/02 10:04 PM
|
Re: Chicken or Egg, continued
|
of troy
|
10/14/02 10:34 PM
|
Re: Chicken or Egg, continued
|
Faldage
|
10/15/02 10:29 AM
|
Re: Chicken or Egg, continued
|
Buffalo Shrdlu
|
10/15/02 12:13 PM
|
Thorny fonts
|
AnnaStrophic
|
10/15/02 12:36 PM
|
Re: Thorn
|
Bobyoungbalt
|
10/16/02 01:50 AM
|
|
Forums16
Topics13,913
Posts229,398
Members9,182
|
Most Online3,341 Dec 9th, 2011
|
|
0 members (),
1,070
guests, and
0
robots. |
Key:
Admin,
Global Mod,
Mod
|
|
|
|