Wordsmith Talk |
About Us | What's New | Search | Site Map | Contact Us | |||
Register Log In Wordsmith Talk Forums General Topics Information and announcements Shakespeare
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Gollub's statement that "altruism vs. ego is a common theme of the tragedies of Shakespeare": this
seems an unsupported notion, given the tragedies themselves. Key, in point, are two of the most well-known:
Hamlet & Romeo&Juliet. IMHO, the only completely altruistic characters in these particular plays are,
respectively, Horatio and Benvolio - neither of whom is, unfortunately, actively involved in the conflict.
Don't these two stand as balance points, or sources of reason, somewhat like a Greek chorus, or Lear's fool? And the very name Benvolio seems to suggest altruistic behavior.
I'm not saying that I agree with Gollub, and your citations well refute what ws said in the short time allotted to him on TV - I just tossed it out as food for thought. As for altruism being dead, I did get hyperbolic, but the world seems so steeped in egoistic corporate power and the de-selfing of the common person (as seen in the term "consumer" usurping the place and implicit rights of "customer") that I go overboard with exaggeration at times.
As for your mentioning Arthur Miller's "All My Sons," I'm more worried about another "Crucible," wherein the righteous kill the right. Dr Bill, you lived through the time Miller wrote about in allegory. Do you not see parallels?
Entire Thread Subject Posted By Posted ![]()
Shakespeare
dxb 04/23/2002 8:06 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
wwh 04/23/2002 8:29 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
Keiva 04/24/2002 12:25 AM ![]()
Post deleted by SilkMuse
SilkMuse 04/25/2002 6:40 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
Jackie 04/25/2002 6:48 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
Faldage 04/25/2002 6:51 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
hev 04/25/2002 10:45 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
Angel 04/25/2002 11:06 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
Jackie 04/26/2002 12:31 AM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
Keiva 04/26/2002 1:11 AM ![]()
Post deleted by SilkMuse
SilkMuse 04/26/2002 12:37 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
maverick 04/26/2002 12:42 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
wwh 04/27/2002 1:32 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
maverick 04/27/2002 9:59 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
wwh 04/27/2002 10:03 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
RhubarbCommando 04/27/2002 8:57 AM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
WhitmanO'Neill 04/27/2002 1:10 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
WhitmanO'Neill 04/26/2002 1:12 AM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
dxb 04/26/2002 3:59 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
Faldage 04/26/2002 4:25 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
Keiva 04/26/2002 4:56 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
WhitmanO'Neill 04/27/2002 1:31 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
Geoff 04/27/2002 1:32 PM ![]()
Post deleted by SilkMuse
SilkMuse 04/27/2002 3:42 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
Geoff 04/27/2002 7:42 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
wwh 04/27/2002 3:54 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
milum 04/27/2002 10:52 PM ![]()
Post deleted by SilkMuse
SilkMuse 04/27/2002 5:31 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
Geoff 04/27/2002 7:59 PM ![]()
Post deleted by SilkMuse
SilkMuse 04/28/2002 1:42 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
Geoff 04/28/2002 3:35 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
alexis 05/06/2002 12:22 PM ![]()
consumer/customer
Fiberbabe 04/28/2002 3:44 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
jmh 04/26/2002 7:45 AM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
maverick 04/26/2002 8:38 AM ![]()
.
Max Quordlepleen 04/26/2002 8:47 AM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
Capital Kiwi 04/26/2002 1:24 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
AnnaStrophic 04/24/2002 4:06 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
Faldage 04/24/2002 4:39 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
Keiva 04/24/2002 5:22 PM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
Geoff 04/24/2002 12:51 AM ![]()
Re: Shakespeare
slithy toves 04/24/2002 2:01 AM ![]()
July 4, 1826
Keiva 04/24/2002 3:09 AM
Moderated by Jackie
Link Copied to Clipboard
Forum Rules · Mark All Read Contact Us · Forum Help · Wordsmith Talk