Wordsmith Talk |
About Us | What's New | Search | Site Map | Contact Us | |||
Register Log In Wordsmith Talk Forums General Topics Q&A about words cheminations
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Oh I do swear by Vox Latina, a thoroughly invaluable slim volume. The one problem I have is the apparent preservation of H in French: after all, virtually all H-initial borrowings from Norman French have a pronounced H in Modern English. (Very few exceptions: 'honour', 'heir', 'hour', and dialectally 'herb'.) The simplest explanation for this is that Latin H stayed pronounced in Gaul until past the Conquest, and then disappeared in France but not in England. However, all the other evidence suggests that H disappeared very early, even as Vox Latina says, within the Classical period.
Now a handful of spelling H's could be turned into pronounced ones by scholarly influence, but the whole lot? So Middle English azard, Ector, eritage, ermit, ideous, omage, Omer, orizon, oroscope, ospital, ost, uman, umble, ydraulic, Ymen, ypolydian, and a great many more all of which could have occurred in Chaucer, were spelt with a silent H (in most cases: Ector, eremite, umble survive without), and at some point the spelling influenced the pronunciation and caused the insertion of an H? It sounds so unlikely -- yet I suppose that's what must have happened.
Entire Thread Subject Posted By Posted ![]()
cheminations
Anonymous 07/09/2001 3:17 PM ![]()
Re: chimenations
maverick 07/09/2001 4:36 PM ![]()
Re: chimenations
maverick 07/09/2001 4:44 PM ![]()
Re: chimenations
Anonymous 07/10/2001 2:41 PM ![]()
Re: chimenations
Faldage 07/09/2001 5:07 PM ![]()
Re: chimenations
belligerentyouth 07/10/2001 7:21 AM ![]()
Re: chimenations
maverick 07/10/2001 9:24 AM ![]()
Re: chimenations
Faldage 07/10/2001 1:01 PM ![]()
Re: chimenations
maverick 07/10/2001 2:12 PM ![]()
Re: Chimbly Nations
Faldage 07/10/2001 3:20 PM ![]()
Re: Chimbly Nations
NicholasW 07/11/2001 10:21 AM ![]()
Re: Chimbly Nations
maverick 07/11/2001 11:19 AM ![]()
Re: Chimbly Nations
Flatlander 07/11/2001 11:25 AM ![]()
Re: Chimbly Nations
maverick 07/11/2001 12:01 PM ![]()
Re: Chimbly Nations
belligerentyouth 07/11/2001 11:39 AM ![]()
Re: Chimbly Nations
Anonymous 07/11/2001 2:40 PM ![]()
Re: It all becomes clear...
Anonymous 07/11/2001 9:46 PM ![]()
Re: It all becomes clear...
NicholasW 07/12/2001 8:30 AM ![]()
Re: It all becomes clear...
Faldage 07/12/2001 1:08 PM ![]()
Re: Chimbly Nations
Faldage 07/11/2001 12:25 PM ![]()
Re: Vox Latina
NicholasW 07/11/2001 1:54 PM ![]()
Re: Vox Latina
Faldage 07/11/2001 2:13 PM ![]()
Re: Mumbling
Faldage 07/10/2001 3:29 PM ![]()
Re: chimenations
Anonymous 07/10/2001 4:06 PM ![]()
Re: chimenations
maverick 07/10/2001 4:37 PM ![]()
Dang it, mav!
Faldage 07/10/2001 4:41 PM ![]()
Re: Dang it, mav!
maverick 07/10/2001 4:47 PM ![]()
Re: Dang it, mav!
Faldage 07/10/2001 4:53 PM ![]()
Re: Dang it, mav!
maverick 07/10/2001 4:58 PM ![]()
Re: Dang it, mav!
wwh 07/10/2001 5:26 PM ![]()
Re: chimenations
Faldage 07/10/2001 4:45 PM
Moderated by Jackie
Link Copied to Clipboard
Forum Rules · Mark All Read Contact Us · Forum Help · Wordsmith Talk