Wordsmith Talk |
About Us | What's New | Search | Site Map | Contact Us | |||
Register Log In Wordsmith Talk Forums General Topics Q&A about words Telephone Etymology
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Here is the comment I received from a Professor of Greek in the US:
The Greek *tElou* and *tEle* "far away" cannot be DERIVED FROM *telos* meaning "end, goal,* etc.
Any imagined derivation of *tElou" or *tEle* from a supposed datival usage of *telos* meaning "at the end" is simply imaginary.
To start with, the quality of the first vowel is wrong since *tElou, tEle* have eta (a long vowel) in the first syllable while *telos* has an epsilon (a short vowel) in the first syllable.
Second, *telos* has a different semantic field. It is related to *tellesthai* and *tellein*. These are the passive form (*telesthati* = "to come to pass") and the active form (*tellein* = "to accomplish") of the same verb. Thus the noun *telos* has as its basic meaning "a coming to pass, performance, consummation, result."
This would seem to me to be a fairly thourough refutation of AWAD's assertion, but AWAD has not issued a rebuttal or a correction as yet.
I'm trying several Word sites to see if anyone can support AWAD's etymology, but so far no one has.
Entire Thread Subject Posted By Posted ![]()
Telephone Etymology
Slava 07/10/2003 1:15 PM ![]()
Re: Telephone Etymology
wwh 07/10/2003 2:20 PM ![]()
Re: Telephone Etymology
tsuwm 07/10/2003 2:46 PM ![]()
Re: Telephone Etymology
Slava 07/10/2003 3:19 PM ![]()
Re: Telephone Etymology
tsuwm 07/10/2003 3:36 PM ![]()
Re: Telephone Etymology
maahey 07/11/2003 1:17 PM ![]()
Re: Telephone Etymology
wwh 07/11/2003 2:19 PM ![]()
Re: Telephone Etymology
Slava 07/11/2003 2:45 PM ![]()
Re: Telephone Etymology
wwh 07/11/2003 3:49 PM ![]()
Re: Telephone Etymology
Slava 07/11/2003 4:39 PM ![]()
Re: Telephone Etymology
Buffalo Shrdlu 07/11/2003 5:00 PM ![]()
Re: Telephone Etymology
tsuwm 07/11/2003 5:29 PM ![]()
Re: Telephone Etymology
Slava 07/12/2003 8:03 PM ![]()
Re: Telephone Etymology
wwh 07/12/2003 8:47 PM ![]()
words from "telos-"
wofahulicodoc 07/13/2003 5:52 PM
Moderated by Jackie
Link Copied to Clipboard
Forum Rules · Mark All Read Contact Us · Forum Help · Wordsmith Talk