Wordsmith Talk |
About Us | What's New | Search | Site Map | Contact Us | |||
Register Log In Wordsmith Talk Forums General Topics Q&A about words Which v That
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
while we wait for Mr. B, here is what alt.usage.english has to say on the matter:
In "The family that prays together stays together", the clause
"that prays together" is called a RESTRICTIVE CLAUSE because it
restricts the main statement to a limited class of family. In
"The family, which is the basic unit of human society, is
weakening", "which ... society" is called a NONRESTRICTIVE CLAUSE
because it makes an additional assertion about the family without
restricting the main statement.
It is generally agreed that nonrestrictive clauses should be
set off by commas; restrictive clauses, not. Nonrestrictive
clauses are now nearly always introduced by "which" or "who"
(although "that" was common in earlier centuries). Fowler
encourages us to introduce restrictive clauses with "that"; but this
is not a binding rule (although some copy-editors do go on "which
hunts"), and indeed is not possible if a preposition is to precede
the relative pronoun. "Which" seem to have more "weight" than
"that"; the weight often just adds starch, but it can be of use
when the relative pronoun is separated from the antecedent: "This
is the only book in my personal library which I haven't read."
Often, too, euphony favours one or the other.
Object relative pronouns can be omitted altogether ("the book
that I read" or "the book I read"); in standard English, subject
relative pronouns cannot be omitted, although in some varieties
of informal spoken English, they are ("There's a man came into
the office the other day").
Entire Thread Subject Posted By Posted ![]()
Which v That
jmh 11/10/2000 7:48 PM ![]()
Re: Which v That
tsuwm 11/10/2000 8:00 PM ![]()
Well Done
Father Steve 11/12/2000 6:45 AM ![]()
Re: Which v That
ammelah 11/12/2000 9:47 AM ![]()
Re: Which v That
tsuwm 11/12/2000 4:35 PM ![]()
Re: Which v That
jmh 11/14/2000 7:15 AM ![]()
Re: Who v That
Avy 12/19/2000 2:45 AM ![]()
Re: Who v That
tsuwm 12/19/2000 5:07 AM ![]()
Re: Who v That
Avy 12/19/2000 6:45 AM ![]()
Re: Who v That
Marty 12/19/2000 9:10 PM ![]()
Re: Who v That
TEd Remington 12/19/2000 12:52 PM ![]()
Spoken vs written issues
shanks 11/13/2000 11:21 AM ![]()
Re: Spoken vs written issues
Bingley 11/14/2000 4:48 AM ![]()
Re: Spoken vs written issues
jmh 11/14/2000 7:56 AM ![]()
Re: Which v That
NicholasW 12/18/2000 3:06 PM ![]()
Re: Which v That
Capital Kiwi 12/18/2000 6:08 PM ![]()
Re: Which v That
wow 12/18/2000 7:30 PM ![]()
Re: Which v That
Father Steve 12/18/2000 7:10 PM ![]()
Re: Which v That
Bobyoungbalt 12/18/2000 8:39 PM
Moderated by Jackie
Link Copied to Clipboard
Forum Statistics Forums16Topics13,916Posts230,311Members9,209 Most Online4,606
Sep 17th, 2025
Newest Members Peripatetic Toad, JerryC, blvd, Tony Hood, Wood Delivery
9,209 Registered Users
Top Posters(30 Days) A C Bowden 11
Top Posters wwh 13,858Faldage 13,803Jackie 11,613wofahulicodoc 11,158tsuwm 10,542LukeJavan8 9,974Buffalo Shrdlu 7,210AnnaStrophic 6,511Wordwind 6,296of troy 5,400
Forum Rules · Mark All Read Contact Us · Forum Help · Wordsmith Talk