barbarianism - Wordsmith.org

You are not logged in. [Log In] Wordsmith.org » Forums » General Topics » Q&A about words » barbarianism

Topic Options

#779 - 03/20/00 07:48 AM barbarianism
sachin stranger Registered: 03/20/00 Posts: 6	Hello everyone, I once heard that the etymology of the word barbarian and related words is that it comes from "bar bar" which is said to be the noise made by "barbarians" when they speak or something like that. Can someone confirm or deny this? Thanks Sachin
Top

#780 - 03/20/00 12:41 PM Re: barbarianism
kritter stranger Registered: 03/20/00 Posts: 1	I was told the same thing by a professor in an english class at college, called "the history and grammar of the english language" my prof really knew his stuff, so i believe him.
Top

#781 - 03/20/00 04:10 PM Re: barbarianism
cadaver stranger Registered: 03/17/00 Posts: 23 Loc: Ohio USA	The OED seems to express that it was not so much who barbarians were, but who they were not. They were not Greek. There is probably a tie-in that the northern coast of Africa was known as the Barbary States.
Top

#782 - 03/22/00 01:49 PM Re: barbarianism
chjones stranger Registered: 03/22/00 Posts: 1 Loc: Chicago, IL	There is a step missing in this etymology, I think. In Latin "barbarian" only means "non-Roman" and was not originally pejorative. The Greek/Latin word "barba" means "beard" (cf. English "barber"), and since Greek and Roman soldiers were required to be clean-shaven (until the Emperor Hadrian grew a beard), it seems likely this is the direct origin of the word "barbarian". Perhaps "barba" then came from the "bar bar" sound made by those that didn't speak Greek.
Top

#783 - 04/02/00 08:26 PM Re: barbarianism
Kostas stranger Registered: 03/15/00 Posts: 2 Loc: Sydney, Australia	My classics teacher supported the theory that the Greeks named other non-Greek tribes as barbarians because of the bar-bar sound of their speech. In Alexandrine times the saying of "all non-Greeks are barbarians" was used by all those who had classical education often as a put-down to the uneducated hoi polloi. However I do not think that the origin of barbarian had much to do with the beards of the non-Greek tribes as the Greeks themselves did grow beards, as one can see on the depictions of battles and heroes on the plethora of ancient Greek pottery and statues. _________________________
Top

Moderator: Jackie

Forum Stats

8424 Members
16 Forums
13686 Topics
209772 Posts

Max Online: 3341 @ 12/09/11 02:15 PM

Newest Members


	Wordsmith Talk		About Us \| What's New \| Search \| Site Map \| Contact Us

Wordsmith Talk