Wordsmith.org
Posted By: Faldage Ending sentences with prepositions - 04/20/04 12:12 PM
If one were to gently chide a grammar nazi for ending a sentence with a preposition, should one use a comma as in "…the preposition, with which the sentence was ended" or not as in "…the preposition with which the sentence was ended"?

Posted By: AnnaStrophic No comma - 04/20/04 12:23 PM
You don't want what looks like a dependent clause just dangling there.

Posted By: Faldage Re: No comma - 04/20/04 12:26 PM
We're saying that it's a restrictive clause?

Posted By: AnnaStrophic Re: No comma - 04/20/04 12:35 PM
I am. But that's just me. Maybe, if you're not in a hurry, we should wait for others to weigh in.

Posted By: Faldage Re: No comma - 04/20/04 01:01 PM
I'm not in a hurry. I checked out the infamous 'Churchill' quote (for which there seems to be no evidence that he ever attually® said it) and there seems to be only one of the many variants that has a comma in it.

http://www.wsu.edu/~brians/errors/churchill.html

I was hoping to hear from Father Steve on this but he's been pretty mum lately.

Posted By: RhubarbCommando Re: No comma - 04/20/04 03:43 PM
A bit ironic, really - Father being mum.

However, on a more serious note, my grammar check (for what little it is worth ) accepts the sentence with or without a comma.
Personally, I prefer it without but I think it might depend a little upon exactly what the beginnig of the sentence said, and how long it took to say.
(i.e., is there a difference, from this point of view, between a simple and a complex sentence?)

Posted By: maverick Re: Ending sentences with prepositions - 04/20/04 05:20 PM
If one were to gently chide a grammar nazi

Don't. It'll end in tears ;)

Posted By: tang grammar nazis - 04/25/04 10:45 PM
If one were to gently chide a grammar nazi ... Don't. It'll end in tears ;)

Or Kristallnacht.

Never in-fuehrer-ate a grammar nazi.
Posted By: Father Steve Re: No comma - 04/27/04 12:16 AM
If a preposition is not that with which to end a sentence, then what is it for?



© Wordsmith.org