My result: Maid (sacrificed for another), John (defended another), Sheriff (kept his bargain, although nothing in the circumstance suggests he could have been made to), and Robin (judgmental prig who hurt the one who sacrificed for him)

Same as Sparteye. Am I alone in believing that there's nothing morally wrong with prostitution? It's the moral equivalent of doctoring, music-making or accounting -- it's all about selling your abilities. To me, the immorality (or at least hypocrisy) is that it's illegal.

I put the Sheriff last for dishonoring his oath of office and using his power to violate Marian.

Yipes! I didn't even think of this! Shows how cynical I am, I guess. Have I become a moral relativist?

As for lying down with the devil -- for how long?