Wordsmith.org
Posted By: wwh ipse dixit - 04/07/04 02:45 PM
The term ipse dixit is the Latin equivalent of the Greek autos epha,
referring to Pythagoras, as in, The master (Pythagoras) said it so it must
be true and no proof is needed. In our modern world, this has many forms:

Child: Why do I have to go to bed at eight every day?
Parent: Because I said so.

Employee: Why do we have to do this project if it's going to be scrapped anyway?
Boss: Because I said so.

An appeal to authority also known as argument from authority, argumentum ad verecundiam (Latin: argument from modesty) or ipse dixit (Latin: he himself, said it), is one method of obtaining propositional knowledge.



Posted By: AnnaStrophic Re: ipse dixit - 04/07/04 06:19 PM
What's the difference in the usage of ipse dixit and quod erat demonstratum?

Posted By: Faldage Re: ipse dixit - 04/07/04 06:27 PM
Ipse dixit would be said after a successful Proof by Blatant Assertion, quod erat demonstrandum after a real proof.

Posted By: Capfka Re: ipse dixit - 04/07/04 08:20 PM
Yup. "Because he says so" ain't QUITE "this is proven".

Posted By: Bingley Re: ipse dixit - 04/08/04 05:27 AM
Actually quod erat demonstrandum doesn't mean 'this is proven', it means 'which was to be proved", i.e., this is what we had to prove. It implies 'and now we have proved it' but it doesn't mean that.

Bingley
Posted By: emanuela Re: ipse dixit - 04/08/04 10:48 AM
indeed, quod erat demonstrandum is usually said/written immediately after the last sentence in a proof, in which we have finished to prove what we had to prove


Posted By: Capfka Re: ipse dixit - 04/08/04 09:12 PM
I know, I know. But the "truth" didn't fit what I wanted to say exactly, so I newsmediaed it.

© Wordsmith.org